When you go into Plehn’s each day, be ready for a surprise. Because the items are made from scratch daily, the inventory for that day depends on the baker’s preference. But you can rest assured that every day, they will have their staple items: coffee cake and kuchens, danishes, donuts, in-house-made brown sugar ham, soups, iced cookies for any occasion (gradation, Halloween, the Kentucky Derby, Easter, Mardi Gras, St. Patrick’s Day, a baby shower) and tried-and-true flavors of their regular cookies: oatmeal, chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, old fashioned sugar, and ice box/thumbprint cookies, which change color seasonally.
They have a variety of seasonal items, in fact. Whether it’s Irish Soda Bread for March 17th, a brownie haunted house for October 31st, a cake shaped like a turkey for Turkey Day, or a Kringle cake with cheese, cinnamon or pecan for the holiday season, you can bring something sweet to the party for any celebration. Or, if you want something colder, try an ice cream cake or a “Cupid’s Delight,” a combo of meringue, ice cream, and whipped icing. And if you trust Plehn’s enough to handle your wedding cake, you can stand tall and proud beside their tiered perfection. But don’t forget the groom’s cake! Serve the groomsmen a baseball park, guitar, or golf bag made out of icing and dough.
Monday – Friday 7am – 6pm
Saturday 6:30am – 5pm
Sunday 6:30am – 1pm
Location(s): 3940 Shelbyville Rd, Louisville, KY 40207
Phone: 502.896.4438 or 502.895.8223